Should Advanced Preschooler Skip Kindergarten?

Gifted preschoolers may appear to be taking in a great deal of data, but they may not truly comprehend it or use it in a gifted manner.
My three-year-old son is currently enrolled in an excellent preschool. The school is doing what we consider to be rather advanced work for his age. He can spell and write most colors and gets weekly spelling tests on a variety of words. He also gets weekly counting tests and can count (and write) the numbers 1 to 100. For daily homework, he gets two pages of English and one page of math. He can also read simple sentences using the words he's learned. He has another year left at the school (next year with the four-year-olds), but we're already worried about what to do with him once he turns five. I've learned that the average kindergarten class is just beginning to teach what he's already learning now. I've also spoken to parents of students who graduated from his preschool and found that kindergarten work was too easy and not stimulating enough for these children.

We don't want our son to become bored and disruptive in kindergarten, so we're thinking of having him tested and skipped into the first grade. We can't imagine that there'd be anything he'd learn in kindergarten that won't be covered in his preschool curriculum. Socially, we think he'd adjust fine. Since he usually plays with his older cousins (six and seven years old), he's in the habit of socializing with older kids already. We hear so many differing opinions on skipping grades when the child is young. We would appreciate some professional advice.

I am amazed! This is absolutely the first time I have ever heard of a nursery school giving homework (other than to bring in a certain colored item, or something that starts with a "b" sound, etc.). I am not certain what the school's rationale is to provide such an intensive curriculum to three-year-olds. I hope that they are also providing lots of time for creative play.

While I am sure your little boy is indeed advanced, we need to remember that most preschoolers learn best in a rote manner. The preschool gifted child will take material learned by rote (the alphabet, for example) and apply it in other ways or use it creatively. What I am saying is that just because the students in this school appear to be taking in a great deal of data, we can not be certain that they are all truly comprehending it and using it in a gifted manner.

To determine your little boy's true academic potential, I would suggest you consider a formal educational assessment. For better accuracy in determining his IQ, it would be best to wait until either after the four-year-old preschool year, or at least until spring of the four-year-old preschool year. No school will permit skipping kindergarten without a full educational assessment. For early entrance or grade skipping, some states require an IQ score of at least 130 or up. By the way, in my home state, kindergarten is required before a child is promoted to the first grade. This law has been in effect here for about a decade. You should check on your state's early entrance policies.

It is important that your son has the advanced social skills that you mention. It is also essential to consider his fine and gross motor skills. First grade will include a lot of writing work, plus skills like using scissors and other art supplies, and organized games.

Research states that to enter a grade early, the child should be at a level of achievement where the program can challenge the student without making special provisions for the child's age or developmental level. You will most likely need to review all the school options available to you to choose the school that best fits your son. You are correct in guessing that the typical kindergarten class is likely to have a curriculum comparable to what your son is experiencing now. However, it may be that if the area preschools are advanced, the grade schools have adjusted and upgraded their kindergarten curriculum. Only your local research will give you that answer. Don't just speak to the school office on the phone. Ask to observe a classroom if possible, and perhaps speak to a PTA member whose child has already completed the kindergarten program.

There are obvious advantages to seeking a challenging program for a gifted child through grade-skipping. There are also disadvantages that I am sure many have already told you (his friends will date and drive before him, he will be smaller in size for sports, etc.). One disadvantage that I never see mentioned is that your child will leave your home one or more years sooner if he is grade-skipped. Sure, he might postpone college but that is not the norm. We only get to have our kids with us for so long and I hesitate to speed up that time without the most extenuating circumstances. Thanks for asking a very interesting question.

Noreen Joslyn is a licensed independent social worker in the state of Ohio and is a member of the Academy of Certified Social Workers. She has a master's degree in Social Work, specializing in family and children, from the University of Pittsburgh. She is a psychiatric social worker in private practice with Ken DeLuca, Ph.D. & Associates, where she counsels parents and children.

Please note: This "Expert Advice" area of should be used for general information purposes only. Advice given here is not intended to provide a basis for action in particular circumstances without consideration by a competent professional. Before using this Expert Advice area, please review our General and Medical Disclaimers.