Child #2 is a seven-year-old boy. He has also been diagnosed as ADHD. He has not tested as gifted yet, but I believe him to be. He was on Ritalin® and then Adderal® for almost two years. The schools were the ones requesting this, as he is very active. But once I saw him at home on the medication, I did not like how it made him. He was zoned, missing everything around him (we were at a baseball game). He has been off medication all summer, and although active, he is retaining things that he learns at an amazing level. He is just high maintenance. My question is, is this so wrong? It seems that we are medicating children too readily, when they require more attention. I would really like your professional opinion on this.
The fact that your older son asked to be taken off the medication is significant; some kids have a good sense of whether or not they need to take medication, and although they can't make the final decision, we need to listen to them. It will be very important to monitor your son's performance very closely in the first few weeks of school to make sure his teachers understand (and can meet) his needs. If he's able to focus and attend outside of school, but has difficulty while there, then you and his teachers need to consider what aspects of school may be causing him difficulty. If he has difficulty in all settings, you can have more certainty about the ADHD diagnosis (and the need for medication).
Is your younger son's school the kind of place that can handle (or embrace) active, eager learners (or as you say, "high maintenance")? If teachers have a hard time accommodating exuberant, quick-witted kids, then a change of classroom (or perhaps school) may be indicated. On the other hand, in order to be successful in life, kids need to learn enough self-control to live and work with other people. If your little one has difficulty containing himself when he needs to, make sure that he's 1) being expected to settle and focus in school and at home, and 2) that he's being taught different ways to gain and maintain self-control and focus. These things need to be done before any thought is given to medication.