crappy friends - FamilyEducation
crappy friends
06/16/2011 at 10:11 AM

This is my first post. When my teen daughter started high school three years ago she didn't know anybody at her public high school because she had gone to a private school for elementary and middle school. She quickly became friends with two girls who have known each other almost their entire lives. She considers them her best friends even though she's always been the "third wheel". I think they are often really inconsiderate towards her and don't treat her like they really value her friendship. They'll sometimes exclude her from plans or cancel plans with her at the last minute when something better comes up. They're all in sports together and the two other girls always sit with one another on the bus to and from events. Never does one of them choose to sit with her. After games they walk together to the locker room and don't wait for her. Yet she still insists they're great friends. I don't get why she puts up with it. I have to bite my tongue not to say to her, "Get a clue, they're treating you like crap". She has other friends she sometimes does things with but still clings to these two. Should I continue to keep my mouth shut about them or when she complains tell her what I really think? It makes me very sad that she doesn't see that she deserves better treatment from friends.

Keep out of it. Having some acquaintances to spend time with is way better than walking through high school all alone. The friendship that those two have with each other is different in nature than the friendship they have extended to your daughter. Fussing about it will only diminish what she has. Why would you do that? Do make opportunities for her to build other friendships, help her find groups/organizations that these two don't participate in. If she doesn't have the relative safety of their company, she might find better, or at least more, friends.
cid
27240

Thanks for your reply. I will keep out of it as much as possible. I guess I will never understand the dynamic between the three of them. The weird thing is, my daughter does have a variety of other friends that she spends time with both in and out of school. But given a choice she'll pick the company of these two girls over other people. It could be that they're supportive towards her in ways that I don't see. I also think she has a sense of loyalty towards them which I think is good, I just hope she doesn't get really hurt at some point. But maybe that's a part of growing up and figuring out what truly close friendships look like.
cid
27242

re: she's always been the "third wheel". I think they are often really inconsiderate towards her and don't treat her like they really value her friendship. >> How do you know this? Does your kid complain about them? re: I don't get why she puts up with it. >> I had a few 'crappy' friends at school because they gave me things I could not get at home! re: I have to bite my tongue not to say to her, "Get a clue, they're treating you like crap". >> Why not? re: She has other friends she sometimes does things with but still clings to these two. >> They meet her needs! re: Should I continue to keep my mouth shut about them or when she complains tell her what I really think? >> I would! re: It makes me very sad that she doesn't see that she deserves better treatment from friends. >> She is getting some needs met from them that is probably missing at home! That's what makes me sad.
cid
27286

Really? You have no ideal what she does or doesn't get at home. I'll tell you several things - she must be getting something positive because she's young for her grade yet is taking all advanced and AP classes and is doing well in them. Also, she's gotten awards in every sport she's been in, plus has been a team captain. Her athletic awards have been for both excellence and sportmanship, so I know we've taught her to treat others well. Oh, and she was also elected onto her school's student council; a position many kids try for but few get selected to do. But you're entitled to make judgements on our home life if it makes you feel better about yourself.
cid
27301

Chrissy, Jim is auditioning for the role of troll on this site. He has a one-size-fits-all response. Just ignore him until he starts making a thoughtful contribution.
cid
27303

I'll go along with that too Mayamay.
cid
27304

Me too!
cid
27305

junieg SnglDad mayamay Ask Host Marti to add an “ignore member” button to this forum to solve your problems with other members here. good luck, jim
cid
27312

Jim, you have all kinds of “advice” to solve everyone else’s problems, have you solved any of your own recently? Just curious. Good luck to you as well.
cid
27552

Double post.
cid
27553

I thought you were making fun of Jimrich's repetitive posts!
cid
27556

Make fun of Jim? I wouldnt do that, it would just give him another reason to play the victim.
cid
27559

Yeah. I was thinking about that meeting where his siblings got in his dad's face, and the dad was explaining how he was raised by an alcoholic father and Jim got all torqued about his dad blaming the alcoholism and other bad behavior on how he was raised.
cid
27564

Don't need a button. I'm doing just fine ignoring peurile comments. Just occasionally I like to rattle the bars of the cage though!
cid
27570

Just occurred to me. Jim wants to be able to ignore ME. Imagine! Jim, simple strategy, If you don't want to see what I have to say about what you think--post in a forum where I don't go. There are lots of them. I even put a link to one of them. But you have to admit, I've done you some good. Now you know how to italicize in this forum. It's a common tool, too. Might work lots of places. See ya around!
cid
27573

Let's keep it friendly, everyone. I really hate to block users from the forums, so I hope everyone can just comment politely on the original posts. Thanks. Cara (Administrator)
cid
27580

That's the whole trouble with this freedom of speech thing, though. It's great that I can tell people what I think, but it's annoying that they can tell me what they think. Funny but a little true. The price you pay for living in a place with freedom.
cid
27584

Hi Chrissy! I am a teenager in high school and i just want you to know that I know people who are in, what it seems like, your daughter's position. No one wants anything to do with these people because their so clicky, and they make trouble. Just ask your daughter why those are her friends, what she actually gets out of the friendship, and ask her about her other friends. If she tends to defend the bad two friends' actions or whatnot, call her out on it. Sometimes that's what us teenagers need.
cid
27615